[Closed] Twisted knee on bad surface Uni Car park advice?

You, for not looking where you're going

(sorry, but it needs saying)

You for not having torch/looking where you're going?

what they said

Gimme an M

gimme a T?

Nothing - Take some personal responsibility

Alternatively, let's smooth over all mountain trails.

Heaven forbid that you might injure yourself.

gimme an F

gimme an U

HTFU

Sorry MTFU

FFS get a grip.

Can the council sue you for being a d!ckhead.. that would be justice done

Ok ok ok (it's normally lit but the lamps were not working)

I'm miffed and MTFU'ing!

Blows dust off the guitar...couple of months mending (A&E say the cartilidge is torn and will need removing) and sells bikes...

how old are you? if my mates 18 month year old falls over, you expect it.

a grown man on the other hand......

Ignore all the self righteous crap talked above. The Uni has a duty to maintain its premises and to provide adequate lighting. Potholes are indicative of them having failed in that duty. Why should you be out of pocket due to their failure to do what they are legally obliged (and paid) to do? That is why they are insured.

I am a solicitor who specialises exclusively in defending insurance claims but in your shoes I would claim. The injury could have long term effects or you may need better/earlier treatment than the NHS will provide. I suggest you contact a solicitor. I can put you in contact with a good one. Email in profile.

Slips and trips aside, the carpark, as a public space, must have been designed to be lit, there are minimum stands to be maintained, not just to stop you tripping over tramps but also to discourage you cars from being burgled and your fellow students from being mugged and raped, and to allow them to go about their business without fear.

Regardless as to how people might feel about our compensation culture I would have expect more than a shrug from the university management. I would expect them to shit themselves.

where there is a blame, there is a new bike............ 😉

My knee-jerk (sorry!) reaction is to say HTFU, but if the surface is badly maintained, the area's inadequately lit and you could reasonably be expected to need to walk across it then I agree with PaulMc.

Keep the wheels of your industry turning eh Paul mc?

The OP has a duty of care to himself. If it's dark be more careful. You might fall.

Please consult the following life coaching video:

You've got to LOL at a solicitor calling other people self-riteous for not supporting their parasitic life-styles.

Don't worry. The recruitment consultants will be along soon to help you out with a job to suit your new circumstances 😀

The OP was hardly running with scissor Algarve

i am a solic.....

stopped reading right about there.

i am a solic.....

stopped reading right about there.

Its a shame if you did because thats where it started to get interesting

When it was normally lit (or in the daytime) didn't you notice that it was uneven and had potholes? Maybe you should have adjusted your walking accordingly?

I'm guessing your parents didn't teach you to not be a moron....

Ah - good point.

Sue the parents.

[i]you may need better/earlier treatment than the NHS will provide[/i]

At that point my cock detector went off.....

Thanks Paul, I left a message for injury specialist who got the money for whiplash physio a few months ago when a driver on his mobile smashed into me and drove off. He said he would look into it even it just pushes the uni to get the land fixed so it doesn't happen again to anyone else.

Students and staff have beem complaining and campaigning to get pot holes fixed for 2yrs...and they just used sand.

I've got an appt with a sports specialist on Friday who is really good who worked with the England rugby team. I have Bupa cover and the NHS is shoddy as I worked for them as a Heamatologist and I was told to cut corners for a lot of patients.

I've just checked my email with transport dept apologising and promising to fix the lights and fill in the pot holes.

Parking cost £120 per year up front.

It wasn't pitch black but the floor was slippery and has been like that for 2 yrs. The floor gave way where it's falling apart and I was being careful!

Anyway enough of the yelling at each other, and thanks for the great advice folks. Hope to back on the bike one day soon!

pathetic claim culture shit. why don't you just accept that you fell over. 'loose sandy/gravel'? what do you ride your bike on?, going to claim for that if you fall off? Do you really want to blame somebody else for your misfortune (cos that's all it is really).

i am clearly not in the claim camp zaskar but best of luck with it chap. just coming back from a beast of an injury myself so know how it feels.
hope it works out sooner rather than later.

Thanks nonk, and agree I'm not into the claim market but I want to make sure the land gets fixed even if I have to get the student union to campaign for it. I think I was lucky as it could be a worse for someone else.

And I didn't fall over Rob, I slipped opening my car door as the floor surface broke apart. I was wearing not slip boots too! Maybe If I crawled like spiderman I'd be ok.

If the Uni does nothing to repair the land after this and is liable and if I have a legal case then I may well indeed claim if I'm within my legal rights.

I'm glad I didn't buy a new carbon road bike btw!

Claim culture sucks, but we're making judgment on the situation based on two lines in the original post, I suppose that's what's been asked for though.

I'd suggest getting good advice from a professional, and make sure you don't bullshit. If there's a genuine fault that caused you injury then that's why they'll have insurance.

Question you have to ask is if it's worth it - misery and stress caused by court cases etc compared to compensation to get a wrong fixed (your knee). If you're looking for cash for a new bike, well, that's not great.

I worked for them as a Heamatologist and I was told to cut corners for a lot of patients.

liable and if I have a legal case then I may well indeed claim if I'm within my legal rights.

so did you cut corners as a haematologist or witness it taking place and did nothing to stop it, if so there might be a few patients/family wanting to speak to your claims lawyer.

just as an extra note before i go to bed; from a purely profesional point of view i would also like to see jusice to the people without blame F'd over by someone who didnt give a sh!t.

gets fixed even if I have to get the student union to campaign for it. I think I was lucky as it could be a worse for someone else.

so as before did you tell your employers to F off and did your job properly or did you accept or even turn a blind eye to others doing it. either way what did you do to stop it. after all the NHS is well shoddy did you do anything to improve this view that people have?

i dont know your story but if you did nothing there might be some kind of symmetry between being asked to cut corners in your haem dept and leaving the job then the driver on the mobile ****tting you and driving off without leaving a name?

please tell all, do you think i might get a juicy finders fee from the claims lawyers against your old trust. if i do i will share 50/50 with you as a matter of courtesy, ill prob split you a bit more if you end up on the wrong end of a court case due to negligence etc.

sorry about your knee by the way hope you back on the bike soon.

I slipped opening my car door as the floor surface broke apart

😆 WTF! How?

Figured it out now...

[img] [/img]

[i]the NHS is shoddy as I worked for them as a Heamatologist and I was told to cut corners for a lot of patients.[/i]

I've worked for the NHS for 20 years now never been told to cut corners, patient care is considered the highest priority and not profit making.

You need to be checked out though as not sure how they could tell you had a torn ligament in A+E.

[i]I slipped opening my car door as the floor surface broke apart[/i]

Exactly the same thing happened to a mate of mine. Admittedly he'd had six pints and clipped the curb a couple of times before reaching the carpark though.

God help them if it snows or gets a bit icy.

Sorry I'm a bit old school. I diislocated my knee whilst running in a park, I stood on that bit were the tarmac meets the grass and went over, properly dislocated my knee and missed a tour of the Alps.
No ones fault but my own.
If I couldn't see where I was putting my feet I'd be a bit careful.

And to the solicitor, how is he out of pocket?

Car parking fees double next year due to compensation claim solicitors.

Anyway the potholes appeared overnight due to the heavy rain didn't they?

Another thing, is it a laid surface car park that's in disrepair or just rough land parking? i.e like a car park at a mountainbike event.

I suggest you contact a solicitor. I can put you in contact with a good one. Email in profile.

Wrong forum. Classifieds is over there ->

18 months, you'd be lucky, I tore mine in 2006, still not soreted to the extent I can ride properly.

NHS will get you walking to the shops and capable of sitting behind a desk again, after that you'r on your own.

Sue the uni if its their fault why should you suffer for 18months or more?

you won't be able to do the usual student shelf stacking/bar work so thats 2 years of lost earnings,

the cost of a knee op is about £2.5k + consultants (£80 a time) and physio (£30-60) and scans (££££), why should you waif 6 months to a year on the NHS referal system, go private and you'll be sorted by the weekend (and probably get a scan first so they'r not operating blind/unececeraly).

I'm still slightly confused as to the rather rapid diagnosis at A&E myself, I had some knee issues and it took several scans and visits to a specialist to sort out what was at fault.

This bulls*it compensation culture will cri[pple the country

take some personal respinsibility

as a MTB'er you should be used to looking out for obstacles

MTFU

Is it just me or is everyone jumping on the String the claimer up bandwagon?? I can't see how your all able to decide that this guys to blame from just a short decsription.

The facts I pulled out of this is someone was injured because of others neglect to properly maintain a public car park that they are charging people to use. I can't say this isnt his fault not knowing all the facts but the Uni has clearly been negligant if they have been informed of issues and not resolved them. This comes down to Uni cutting costs at the expense of public safety.

I ripped a ligament in my thumb a few years ago snowboarding. I still have use of it but because of its weak state I can no longer play basketball (i'd cry if you through a passed a ball to me hard) and I'll never climb is strongly as I once did. No one was to blame in this situation but If i'd have done this at work on the steps that get slippy in the wet (the ones that nearly every member of staff has complained about over the last 5 years) then i'd be stringing the f@@ckers up.
Why should I never play ball again because some management are cutting corners??

I don't agree with this compansation Nation we have but that is purely becasue so many people take the pi$$. I do think it helps to make people in postitions of responsibility accountable for their own inactions though.

The facts are that an intelligent man walked across an area of uneven ground, the uneveness of which was well known, in the dark; a lack of illumination that was also pre-evident.
I put it to you, ladies and gentlemen of the jury, that any injury subsequent to this is largely the fault of the universe...